Lighting technology has changed dramatically in the last decade, with LEDs becoming the go-to choice for nearly every application. But many buyers still wonder: what’s the difference between LED and lamp-based fixtures, and when does one make more sense than the other?
We sat down with Andrew Dranetz, Senior Sales Associate at PORT Lighting, to break it down for buyers.
The Main Difference Between LED and Lamp-Based Fixtures
“The truth is, LED has essentially taken over the entire lighting industry,” says Andrew. “Incandescent, fluorescent, and most discharge lamp options have been replaced by LED, except in very rare cases.”
At their core, the difference is simple:
-
Lamp-based fixtures use a replaceable bulb that eventually burns out.
-
LED fixtures are solid-state units, built to last far longer with far less maintenance.
Advantages of Each Technology
LED Fixtures
-
Longevity: LEDs last up to 150 times longer than many lamp options.
-
Energy Efficiency: They draw significantly less power, reducing utility costs.
-
Lower Heat Output: Less strain on HVAC systems translates to further savings.
-
Rebates & Incentives: Many utility companies provide financial incentives for switching.
Lamp-Based Fixtures
-
Lower Upfront Cost: A handful of theatrical fixtures are still offered at a lower initial price point than LEDs.
-
Familiarity: For venues already built around lamp-based infrastructure, swapping bulbs may feel like the simplest solution in the short term.
When Lamp-Based Fixtures Still Make Sense
Andrew admits it’s rare. “I’d be hard-pressed to justify a lamp-based fixture unless cost was the deciding factor. Some theatrical fixtures are still sold in limited models, and they can save money upfront compared to LEDs.”
For most buyers, however, LEDs quickly offset the initial cost through energy and maintenance savings.
Who Benefits Most from LEDs?
“Honestly, everyone,” Andrew says. “As long as cost isn’t the obstacle, LEDs have solutions for every imaginable lighting need.”
From small venues to major theaters, commercial spaces to houses of worship, LEDs adapt to virtually any environment.
Common Misconceptions About LEDs
The biggest hesitation Andrew sees is sticker shock.
“In some cases, the upfront cost can be a deterrent. But once buyers understand the long-term return on investment, the savings always make sense.”
Do Buyers Ever Mix the Two?
For new installations? Almost never.
“For existing setups, though, it’s common,” Andrew explains. “Venues often upgrade gradually, maybe all the CYC lights one year, then all the front lights later so you’ll see LEDs and lamp-based fixtures coexisting during that transition.”
The Bottom Line
LED technology is the industry standard, offering unmatched efficiency, longevity, and performance. Lamp-based fixtures may still have a place in cost-driven decisions, but for most buyers, LEDs deliver greater value over time.
As Andrew puts it: “There are LED solutions for every lighting need. It’s just a matter of when you’re ready to make the switch.”
Looking to upgrade your lighting? Explore PORT Lighting’s curated selection of LED fixtures and find the right solution for your venue.
